May 21, 2005

The Fed starts backing down health of Real Estate Market

From the Wall Street Journal: The Fed Starts to Show Concern Over Bubble.
For a long time, Federal Reserve Chairman Alan Greenspan dismissed suggestions that the U.S. was in the early stages of a housing bubble. He talked about the extraordinary demand for houses among hard-working immigrants. He emphasized that housing, unlike stocks, is a local market, so it's almost impossible to have a national housing bubble. He explained that it's hard to speculate in a house that you own because to sell it you have to move out.
But there has been a little more concern creeping into his commentary in the past few months. "We do have characteristics of bubbles in certain areas, but not, as best I can judge, nationwide," he told a House committee in February. Mr. Greenspan speaks to the Economic Club of New York at lunchtime tomorrow. If housing comes up in his remarks or if he is questioned on the subject by one of the prominent economists there, look for the Fed chairman to mention -- as Fed Governor Donald Kohn did recently -- the upturn in people buying vacation homes, second homes or other homes on the risky bet that housing prices will continue to rise as they have lately.

Mr. Greenspan hasn't yet hit the "irrational exuberance" gong, the phrase he used to warn about the stock market in December 1996. The Fed and other bank regulators, however, this week warned banks to take more care with home-equity loans, noting that such loans are "subject to increased risk if interest rates rise and home values decline." (Did you say decline? Gulp.) Even a slowing of the pace of increase in housing prices probably would dent consumer spending, which, for the past couple of years, has been helped by Americans tapping their home equity.
Other Fed officials have begun to express some anxiety. In a speech last month, Mr. Kohn said, "A couple of years ago I was fairly confident that the rise in real-estate prices primarily reflected low interest rates, good growth in disposable income and favorable demographics." Mr. Kohn was a longtime adviser to Mr. Greenspan before his appointment to the Fed board.
No longer. "Prices have gone up far enough since then relative to interest rates, rents and incomes to raise questions; recent reports from professionals in the housing market suggest an increasing volume of transactions by investors, who...may be expecting the recent trend of price increases to continue," Mr. Kohn said.
Interestingly, the one place I saw these speeched headlined, the headline was "Greenspan say no real estate buble". I guess the story is the improbable rise of real estate, not the risk of the real estate market. The thing is that Greenspan only ever speaks about the national market in the aggregate because that's his job. Its not his job to manage regional economies (in fact, that might interfere with his management of the national economy). When he finally recognizes a real estate bubble, it will only be because it has reached national proportions. Posted by dapkus at May 21, 2005 12:38 PM